Therefore, I propose that we use one of the following three options:
=> Allow trolling:
Advantages
- Promotes skill-based bagging
- Promotes attentiveness and frontrunning skill
- Balances out the shock-dodging metagame (since trolling counters dodging)
- Zero confusion about rules or penalties
- Additional factors to take into account in track selection and racing strategy
Disadvantages
- A number of teams will likely leave, or threaten to leave, the league
- Gives shit clans something else to blame their losses on, i.e. more drama
=> Disallow single-target item hits:
(i.e. allows shocks, pows and bloopers but nothing else; wheelie bumps, goldens, box stealing/camping are all fair game)
Advantages
- Minimal confusion
- A good compromise between the other two options
- Extremely easy to prove via video evidence
- Any item hits are entirely the bagger's fault
Disadvantages
- Doesn't solve the core issue (i.e. that the trolling rule is cumbersome and overly complicated)
- Loopholes will be discovered, which will require additional rules, thus defeating the point of simplifying the trolling rule in the first place
- Doesn't solve any of the usual proof-call drama surrounding trolling
=> Disallow all item use/being lapped:
(penalty either for item use or being lapped, or even both; proof by minimap)
Advantages
- No loopholes or ambiguity.
- Promotes 5v5 play instead of 4v4 + 1v1.
- Getting a lap behind unintentionally only happens if people are legitimately awful (gv2 included)
- Makes wars 6 minutes shorter just by not having to wait for baggers to time out/having to reset for people who accidentally dc'd while bagging
Disadvantages
- In the current metagame, shock battles will move from two laps behind the pack to one lap minus a few seconds. (i.e. bagging will become more about who is more willing to risk being lapped than who is actually better at bagging)
- Will lead to drama over whether or not someone is actually lapped
- Completely removes skill from the equation in bagging
I'm leaning towards option A, Allow Trolling. If I've missed anything in this post, please feel free to point it out.
Also, personal preference is irrelevant here. After all, if personal preference meant anything, I'd be asking for 6v6 Australian only backwards races where the lowest score wins.
Last edited by flc on Wed Mar 20, 2013 6:08 pm; edited 1 time in total